Talk:Halloween Event (2010)/@comment-3071046-20101102093235

I'm looking for some opinions. From October 28th to November 1st this page had its very large number of items separated into sections (Animals, Building, Decorations, etc) and alphabetized making navigation easier and making the elimination of duplicate entries much easier. You can see that approach by viewing the history or by clicking here:

http://farmville.wikia.com/index.php?title=Halloween_Event_(2010)&oldid=106890

However an administrator of this wiki deemed that approach no good because this wiki "has never done that before" and so we must never do that -- in other words there is no room for different ideas, even if those ideas might be better.

http://farmville.wikia.com/index.php?title=User_talk:Alanfeld&oldid=108360#An_advice

Readers and contributors of this wiki, what are your thoughts? Do you like having 65 items all crammed together into one incredibly long list without any separation or alphabetization resulting in duplicate entries and making it hard to find any items? If so, what are the benefits to that approach (other than "we've always done it that way").

Or do you prefer the separation and alphabetization introduced in the link I provided above? Just wondering what your thoughts are. Thanks.